Monica Lawrence has always jumped from one relationship to the next, afraid of ending up alone. Now, at age 32, she is married and miserable, catering to her verbally abusive husband, Saleem. But Monica's unfulfilled life grinds to a halt when Saleem's cousin Frankie comes to town to plan his wedding with his fiance, Bianca. To Monica's surprise, she is reunited with Frankie, who happens to have been her first love. As old feelings surface, relationships are tested and everyone is faced with either doing what's right or following their hearts.